Baldwin denim fit review: Henley vs South 4th Street skinny jeans

Baldwin jeans review: Henley vs Williamsburg Garment Co. men’s skinny fit


Here we analogize and review Williamsburg South 4th Street skinny jeans to Baldwin’s Henley slim fit jeans. Both brands make American made jeans, with a focus on raw denim. All South 4th Street jeans are made with stretch fabric for a great level of comfort.

In review of the size charts, we believe that the same size would be worn in both styles. The overall measurements of the Williamsburg jeans are smaller, just as a skinny vs slim jean comparison should be. Expect the Williamsburg jeans to have a bit less excess fabric being that it’s a skinny jean and will therefore be more form fitting.

S 4th St raw denim stretch selvedge skinny jeans made in USA

Williamsburg Garment Co.

South 4th St. - Skinny Fit

Baldwin Henley selvedge raw denim slim American made jeans


Henley - Slim Fit

Waist (Measured along top WB) Size:30

31 1/2"


Seat (Measured 8"below WB)



Front Rise (Including WB)


9 1/2"

Thigh (Measured 1" Below Crotch)


22 3/4"

Leg Opening

13 1/2"

14 1/2"







Fabric Comments

11.5 oz Stretch Selvedge

14.5 oz Selvedge Rigid

Suggested Retail Price



Country of Make




Measurements are taken from actual store bought samples. Our recorded specs may differ from a brands official spec as sometimes final production products slightly differ from targeted measurements, or we may measure slightly different than other jeans brands.

When comparing sizing from top denim brands, please note, we use total circumference measurements, while others may use 1/2-circumference measurements in fit charts. Some information when not available to us may be taken from the brands website or a brands retailers websites. In no way do we state our specs or other information related to competing denim brands is 100% accurate. To get the most accurate info on all brands products you should always refer to that brands website or contact the brand directly.